Will My Case Go to Trial, or Can It Be Settled Out of Court?

The trajectory of a personal injury case, whether it goes to trial or is resolved through an out-of-court settlement, hinges on a multitude of factors and the unique dynamics of each case. To provide a more comprehensive understanding, let's explore in greater detail the considerations that determine whether a case is settled or proceeds to trial, along with relevant examples:

  • Settlement Out of Court: Settling a personal injury case out of court is a common and often preferred resolution. In this scenario, the parties involved—usually the injured individual and the at-fault party or their insurance company—engage in negotiations to reach a mutually acceptable agreement on compensation. Several factors may influence the decision to settle:
  • Time and Cost: Trials can be time-consuming and expensive. Settling out of court can save both parties substantial time and legal fees.
  • Predictability: Trials involve inherent uncertainties, as the outcome depends on the judge or jury's decision. In contrast, settlements offer greater predictability in the compensation amount.
  • Privacy: Settlements are confidential, allowing the parties to maintain their privacy without the details of the case becoming public.
  • Resolution Control: Parties have more control over the outcome in a settlement. They can negotiate terms that address specific needs and concerns.


Suppose an individual sustains severe injuries in a slip and fall accident at a grocery store. The injured party, represented by their personal injury lawyer, enters negotiations with the store's insurance company. After assessing the evidence and potential legal costs, the insurance company offers a settlement amount to compensate for the medical expenses and pain and suffering. If the injured party finds the offer acceptable, they may choose to settle the case out of court and avoid a lengthy trial.

  • Proceeding to Trial: In certain instances, a fair and agreeable settlement cannot be reached through negotiations. Factors that might lead to proceeding to trial include:
  • Disagreement on Liability: If there is a significant dispute over who is at fault for the accident or the extent of responsibility, parties may prefer to let a judge or jury decide the matter.
  • Inadequate Settlement Offers: If the insurance company's settlement offer is unreasonably low and does not adequately compensate for the injuries and damages, the injured party may opt for a trial to pursue a fair resolution.
  • Policy Limits: In some cases, the at-fault party's insurance policy may have limits that prevent a sufficient settlement. A trial may be pursued to explore additional avenues for compensation.
  • Precedent Setting: In certain complex or high-profile cases, parties may go to trial to establish legal precedents that can impact similar cases in the future.


In a motorcycle accident case, the injured motorcyclist suffers catastrophic injuries due to a negligent driver. The at-fault driver's insurance company disputes the severity of the injuries and offers a minimal settlement that would not cover the extensive medical treatment required. As a result, the injured motorcyclist decides to take the case to trial to seek appropriate compensation and hold the responsible party accountable.

In conclusion, whether a personal injury case is settled out of court or proceeds to trial is influenced by a range of factors, including the willingness of both parties to negotiate, the evidence and legal arguments presented, the extent of injuries and damages, and the overall complexities of the case. Experienced personal injury attorneys can provide valuable guidance on the most suitable course of action based on the specifics of your case and advocate for your best interests throughout the legal process.

Wolfson & Leon, a reputable personal injury law firm, has been standing up for personal injury victims since 1963. Our accomplished accident attorneys have vast experience across all types of personal injury cases. If you seek clarity or guidance on your case, contact us at (305) 285-1115. We proudly serve clients in Miami, Fort Myers, Hialeah, Cape Coral, Tampa, Orlando, Fort Lauderdale, West Palm Beach, and South Florida. Give us a call today, and our dedicated team will address all your questions.

Client Reviews
I was rear-ended on my motorcycle by a distracted driver. I broke my leg, lost two fingers and my entire life changed. I searched Google and came upon Jonah Wolfson. His reviews were quite impressive. Within five months, my case was entirely settled. JONAH IS A BULLDOG WHO WILL REPRESENT YOU AND BE BY YOUR SIDE UNTIL THE BITTER END. HE TRULY CARES ABOUT YOU AND WILL ADVOCATE FOR YOU WITH HIS TEAM. Thank you for helping get me through this with compassion, honor and stealth. You are my hero Mr. Wolfson. God bless you! Cindy
Mr. Wolfson helped me tremendously with my car accident. He was able to represent me with care and respect while fighting hard to get my case resolved. I live a busy life and being able to go about my day and not worrying about my case was a huge relief because I knew I was in good hands. I wasn't just another client to him and that's what makes the difference. Thank you again Mr. Wolfson! Michael
All I can say is WOW! I have never met such a professional law team. They are caring and put your needs above money. I guess to describe them is fair, kind, and professional. Don't be fooled by the other attorneys who only want your money. By far the best attorneys in Florida! Marina Barber
I absolutely love this firm! It's personalized, you always have someone on the phone and you literally feel like family. They were always on top of my case and I felt supported the whole time my case was being settle. I got what I need it and what I deserved! Totally recommend them! They are the good attorneys for real! Dora
Wolfson & Leon took my case and did everything they said they were going to do followed up with me to let me know what was going on and were very professional and were able to win me a larger settlement then I anticipated. I give them five stars for excellent representation. Russ